Skip to content

U.S. men’s figure skaters mired in quad quandary

Oct 21, 2013, 11:03 AM EDT

Max Aaron Getty Images

DETROIT — Down went Max Aaron. Down went Adam Rippon.

It’s the hardest puzzle piece to snap into place in men’s figure skating leading up to the Sochi Olympics: the quadruple jump. And after the season’s first Grand Prix event, it continues to be an elusive element for the top U.S. men.

Only Skate America’s winner, Tatsuki Machida of Japan, made it through the weekend without any trouble with four-revolution jumps, landing two in his free skate to win over Rippon and Aaron, who took silver and bronze, respectively.

Daisuke Takahashi, the 2010 Olympic bronze medalist, barely caught his quadruple toe loop and struggled Saturday to finish fourth.

Can the American men find their quad form come Sochi?

Evan Lysacek was criticized in 2010 for winning gold in Vancouver without a quad. While Lysacek remains out with injury, two-time Olympic silver medalist Elvis Stojko, who helped usher in the jump to men’s skating in the 1990s, is a fan of the bigger-is-better movement.

“Guys are trying two quads in a program, which is awesome,” Stojko said last week. “I feel that they’re really pushing the envelope. Now they’re back to what we were doing in 2002 in the quads. There’s more guys doing it and more consistently, which is great. So, having at least one quad in the program is a must, if you want to be in the hunt. If you really want to take down the competition, doing two with a combination.”

The toe loop has been a struggle for Aaron, who landed two quad salchows Saturday night.

“Right now we’re committed to keeping that quad toe loop in there; we’re not going to take it out,” Aaron said. “Maybe by Boston (U.S. Championships in January) it will be perfect, maybe it will not.”

Aaron has a whopping three quads in his free skate, compared to just one in Rippon’s. The silver medalist made light of his fall Saturday night, in which he hit the boards.

“I’m lucky that the Joe Louis is an old, sturdy arena,” Rippon said, drawing laughs. “The boards held up and didn’t break.”

But Rippon, who was second at Nationals in 2012, got serious a few minutes later, saying that he planned to add one, if not two quad jumps to his program this season.

“My priority for each competition is to go out and put out a good quad lutz,” he said. “By the end of the season I hopefully will add another quad lutz and also a quad toe to the program. The quad toe has been good at home in practice.”

Other Americans in contention to make the Sochi Olympic team, including Ross Miner and three-time national champion Jeremy Abbott, have quads but have not been able to execute them on a consistent basis.

For many skaters it is a numbers game. Figure skating’s “new” scoring system, which has now been around for nearly 10 years, awards higher totals for the bigger jumps, even if they aren’t executed perfectly.

“I left a lot of points on the table,” said Aaron, referring to the fall and subsequent mistakes around his quads. “It was unacceptable for me to fall. I’m not very happy about that.

“I’m going to go back home and continue to work. We want the components a lot higher, we want the technical score a lot higher and we want the overall score a lot higher. We’re not looking for falls or step outs; we’re looking for a clean skate every time. We will get it right. We picked that program for a reason and there’s no backing down.”

Plushenko updates on his training

  1. caseyedwardsd - Oct 21, 2013 at 5:56 PM

    The new system has not been the same for 10 years. In 2010 the olympics took place under a version that punished quad failure extremely harshly. That version which was in place from 2007 to 2010 could make a landed quad a little underrotated go from 9.8 points to 1 point. Now it would be 4 or 5!! There has been a radical adjustment in the scoring system and that’s why quads are back. If things didn’t change no one would be doing quads now just like they were vanishing from 2007 to 2010. But the horrible victory of lysacek made them change the system so there was some technical merit again.

  2. janessa31888 - Oct 22, 2013 at 9:04 AM

    Evans victory was NOT horrible!!!!!!!! I am so sick of this whining. Its over. MOVE on.
    I’m not worrying about Max because he’s proven he can land quads and its still early in the season. Adam is very close to landing a quad lutz, which is really hard. On the other hand, I haven’t seen Jeremy land one since the 2010 nationals. Which is probably why he has never won a medal at the World Championships.

  3. katra2logic - Oct 23, 2013 at 11:11 PM

    My wife has been a figure skater all her life and has an encyclopedic knowledge of the sport. She says the new scoring system saved skating and is the most important step forward in figure skating history. Although less knowledgeable, I have been with her these past 23 years and know far more about the sport than I ever intended. At least now you know where you need to improve, the old 6.0 system didn’t provide any feedback to the athletes other than their position of finish. Cheers :-)

    • katra2logic - Oct 23, 2013 at 11:16 PM

      Almost forgot the most important part of the new scoring system. It makes judges accountable. Plus there is a technical panel to make sure the elements were completed properly. A much more systematic, sensible and fair way to run a competition. Cheers :-)

Leave Comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!